Just finished watching All Star Superman with my wife and kids. It was awesome! Obviously they could no include EVERYTHING from the comics so I kept that in consideration as I watched it.
All-in-all I think McDuffie did an excellent job with this one (as if one could expect any less from him). I am especially happy that he left out the bizzaro world part of the comics as that was my least favorite part of that excellent read (not to mention it would have been externally difficult to do the voice acting for the bizzaro characters and even more confusing to casual fans/viewers).
I’m so glad I own this on DVD so I can watch it again and again! Though the blu-ray would be nice too as it has lots of awesome extras (look out bro, you got the better end of this deal)!